A Study Guide to the Gospel of Mark Chapter 8 – You Are the Christ

Writer: 
Pasi Hujanen

Read or listen The Gospel of Mark, Chapter 8 online (ESV, YouVersion)


The Second Feeding Miracle – Mark 8:1–10

Some regard this account merely as a repetition of the miracle of the feeding of the 5,000 described in Mark 6:30–44, but Jesus himself refers to two feeding miracles (Mark 8:19–20). Although these two accounts share many common features, they also contain many different details.

Matthew also tells of the second feeding miracle (Matt 15:32-39), but Luke and John only tell of the first feeding miracle.

An interesting detail is that in the paintings found in the catacombs in Rome depicting the miracle of the feeding, there are seven baskets—just as in this account and in Matthew 15:32–39.

This time, the people had already gone three days without eating (verse 2). There were not even any villages nearby where one could go to buy food (verse 4).

In verse 7, an accurate translation of the Greek text would be: "...gave thanks (to God) for the fish."

After the miracle, Jesus got into a boat and crossed the Sea of ​​Gennesaret. The location of Dalmanutha (verse 10) is unknown. Matthew mentions the region of Magadan (Matt 15:39), and some manuscripts of Matthew refer to Magdala—the home of Mary Magdalene. It is unclear whether Dalmanutha and Magadan were two different names for the same place, or if the two locations were situated near each other.

This miracle of feeding took place in the region of the Decapolis—that is, an area inhabited by Gentiles. Indeed, the mention in verse 3 of people having come “from far away” has been interpreted as a reference to Gentiles.

These two feeding miracles contain a detail that points toward missionary work. In the first miracle—which took place in a Jewish region—there were twelve baskets of leftovers, corresponding to the number of the apostles. In the second miracle, there were seven baskets of leftovers, corresponding to the number of the deacons (Acts 6:1–6). These feeding miracles foreshadow missionary work: God desires to share His word with both Jews and Gentiles. It was the apostles’ task to proclaim it to the Jews, while the development of the mission to the Gentiles began with the deacons.

Jesus is Asked to Give a Sign – Mark 8:11-13

Once again, the Pharisees wanted to argue with Jesus (verse 11; cf. Mark 2:24, 3:2, 7:1–2). Mark uses the same Greek word for "testing" (verse 11) as is used when Satan tests Jesus in the wilderness (Mark 1:13). Satan also demanded a sign from Jesus (Matt 4:3, 6).

A sign from heaven (verse 11) meant more than an "ordinary" miracle. It signified God’s direct intervention in the course of events—a miracle originating from heaven. Elijah caused fire to fall from heaven (1 Kings 18:38–39).

Perhaps the Pharisees had in mind Moses’ prophecy that, one day, a prophet like him—the Messiah—would come:

..."I will raise up for them a prophet like you from among their brothers. And I will put my words in his mouth, and he shall speak to them all that I command him."
(Deuteronomy 18:15, 18, ESV)

John 6:14 refers to this in connection with the miracle of the feeding:

"When the people saw the sign that he had done, they said,
“This is indeed the Prophet who is to come into the world!”"
(John 6:14, ESV)

Immediately following that prophecy, there is a warning about false prophets (Deuteronomy 18:20) and an exhortation to test the prophets (Deuteronomy 18:21–22). We can say that the actions of the Pharisees were evil cloaked in holiness.

Others also performed miracles during the time of Jesus (Matt 12:27; cf. Matt 24:24, Rev 13:13), so the Pharisees felt fully justified in demanding that Jesus provide proof that he was a genuine prophet sent by God. He could demonstrate this by giving a sign from heaven.

Jesus, however, refused to provide further evidence (verse 12). Nothing can convince an unbelieving heart (Matt 12:39; Luke 11:29, 16:28–31). The problem with the Pharisees was not that Jesus had failed to demonstrate the source of his actions. Their problem was unbelief, and that cannot be cured even by the greatest of miracles.

The deep sigh (verse 12) was an indication of Jesus’s frustration with the Pharisees’ unbelief. "This generation" was rebellious and unbelieving, just as Israel had been so many times throughout its history (cf. Deut 32:5, 20).

Jesus returned to the eastern shore of the Sea of ​​Gennesaret (verse 13). His visit to the Jewish region had stirred his opponents into action, but soon Jesus would leave Galilee altogether, and the final confrontation would take place in the center of Judaism—Jerusalem.

The Disciples’ Lack of Understanding – Mark 8:14–21

The mention of a single loaf in verse 14 can likely be seen as a reference to the fact that Jesus is the only true bread of life (compare John 6:22–59).

Leaven (verse 15) is the root of bread. In the Bible, it generally represents something evil—something unacceptable to God—which, moreover, has a tendency to spread to its surroundings and permeate the entire person or society (Leviticus 2:11, Matthew 16:12, Luke 12:1, 1 Corinthians 5:6–8, Galatians 5:9).

Mark has already mentioned (Mark 3:6) that the Pharisees and the supporters of Herod had joined forces with the intention of killing Jesus. It has been asked what brought the Pharisees and the supporters of Herod together (verse 15). The Pharisees sought to isolate themselves from the world into their own "spiritual perfection." Herod's supporters prioritized political tactics. Thus, both groups had elevated their own desires and ideas above the kingdom of God.

Mark emphasizes the disciples’ lack of understanding. They, too, were blind and deaf to the works of God (verse 18; cf. Mark 4:13, 40; 6:52; 7:18). This is a sign of hardness of heart (verse 17).

The Healing of a Blind Man – Mark 8:22-26

Bethsaida (verse 22) was located east of the Jordan River—that is, in a Gentile region, outside of Galilee. Although a portion of Bethsaida also lay on the west bank of the Jordan, the Bethsaida referred to here was the part of the settlement situated in the Gentile territory.

Bethsaida means "House of the Catch," "Fishing Hut," or "Fishing Shore." At least three of Jesus' disciples came from there (John 1:44: Peter, Philip, and Andrew). In Matthew 11:20–21, Jesus mentions that He had performed many miracles in Bethsaida. In the Gospels, only this healing of a blind man is reported, and it appears only in the Gospel of Mark.

Once again (verse 22; cf. Mark 7:32), Jesus was asked to heal a man by laying His hands on his head. Jesus withdrew to a private place with the person to be healed (verse 23). Miracles are not public entertainment. On this occasion, too, Jesus used saliva for the healing (verse 23; Mark 7:33).

This time, the healing took place "in stages." At first, the man’s vision was only partial (verse 24), but then he was completely healed (verse 25). Perhaps Mark intended to highlight that even spiritual blindness (compare verses 18, 29, and 33) is often healed in stages, rather than all at once. On the other hand, a gradual healing process might reflect the severity of the injury or the gravity of the illness.

Jesus once again demonstrated his messianic identity by providing the sign demanded by the Pharisees: the healing of the blind was one of the signs of the Messiah (Isaiah 42:6–7).

"I will give you as a covenant for the people, a light for the nations, to open the eyes that are blind, to bring out the prisoners from the dungeon, from the prison those who sit in darkness."
(Isaiah 42:6–7)

Who is Jesus? Mark 8:27–30

Caesarea Philippi was the administrative seat of the tetrarch Philip, located on the slopes of Mount Hermon (verse 27). It was a pagan territory—or, to be more precise, some rabbis considered the Jewish territory to extend exactly that far, meaning it lay on the border of a pagan region. The site was a place of worship for the god Pan; hence its former name, Panias—a name that has come back into use in modern times. Today, the place is called Banias. One of the sources of the Jordan River is in this area.

Earlier (Mark 6:14–16), Mark had recounted the various speculations among the people regarding John the Baptist. The same speculations were also put forward regarding Jesus (verse 28).

It is important to note that, even today, God does not ask us what others think of Jesus; rather, the most important question is: "What do you think of Jesus?" (verse 29) Jesus also asks us: “Who do you say that I am?”

The words Christ and Messiah mean the same thing—that is, the Savior, the Anointed One.

At this stage, however, Jesus had to keep the fact that He was the Messiah a secret (verse 30), because the people were expecting an earthly king. Even the disciples did not understand what kind of Savior God had sent into the world (compare verses 31–33). Jesus still had to teach even His own disciples what kind of Messiah He was—and is.

Peter’s confession differs from the speculations of the people in that the people regarded Jesus as the one who prepares the way for the Messiah, whereas Peter saw Him as the Messiah Himself. The waiting had come to an end. The Messiah had arrived.

After Peter’s confession, Jesus no longer taught or healed in Galilee amidst large crowds. The path toward the cross of Golgotha ​​had begun, and Jesus focused on teaching His disciples (cf. Mark 9:30).

Peter’s confession also signified a deeper commitment to Jesus. One could change a rabbi or a teacher, but there is only one Savior—one Messiah. Matthew emphasizes that Peter did not grasp Jesus’ messiahship on his own; rather, it was the work of God within him:

"And Jesus answered him, “Blessed are you, Simon Bar-Jonah! For flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my Father who is in heaven.'"
(Matt 16:17, ESV)

We, too, must remember that reason leads us astray in matters of faith. We can find the right path only through the work that God has done within us.

The First Prediction of Suffering – Mark 8:31-34

Once the disciples had grasped that Jesus was the Messiah, the time had come to show them what kind of Messiah he was (verse 31). The Jewish expectation of the Messiah did not include the idea of ​​a suffering Messiah, but rather that of a victorious rebel leader who would become a new Davidic king (Mark 11:9–10). Knowing this expectation, it is not surprising that Peter was horrified by Jesus' words about suffering and death (verse 32).

However, Jesus did not seek to fulfill people’s expectations and desires (Luke 24:21), but rather the will of God—His plan of salvation. On two further occasions, Mark records that Jesus spoke to His disciples about His suffering and death (Mark 9:31; 10:33–34), yet His death on the cross still came as a surprise to them. They could not grasp that Jesus would truly lay down His life for the sins of the world (cf. Mark 9:32).

Do we have the same problem? Are we also able to accept from God only something that fits our preconceptions and desires? We, too, should remember that the ways of God and the ways of man do not follow the same paths (verse 33; Isaiah 55:8–9).

"For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, declares the Lord . For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways and my thoughts than your thoughts."
(Isaiah 55:8-9, ESV)

This is especially true regarding salvation: we would like to save ourselves, but God Himself wants to save us.

The word "teach" (verse 31) indicates that the idea of ​​the Messiah’s suffering and death was so new and surprising to the disciples that it required not merely an explanation, but the teaching of something entirely new.

The elders of the people, the chief priests, and the teachers of the law (verse 31) were members of the Jewish Great Council, the Sanhedrin, which condemned Jesus to death (Mark 14:53–65).

The expression "the Son of Man" (verse 31) originated from the prophecy in Daniel 7:13, where the original language uses the phrase "like a son of man". Jesus frequently used this messianic title to refer to himself.

The word "must" (verse 31) corresponds to the Greek term "dei", which denotes a divine necessity. Jesus’ suffering and death were not a matter of chance; rather, they were the will of God, as foretold by Isaiah (Isaiah 53).

"Reject" (verse 31) could also be translated as "deem Him unfit" or "consider Him unworthy." Jesus was not accepted by the Jewish leaders as the Messiah. Even the rejection of the Messiah was foretold in the Old Testament: Psalm 118:22 (cf. Mark 12:10; 1 Peter 2:4):

"The stone that the builders rejected has become the cornerstone."
(Ps 118:22)

Note that Jesus speaks not only of His suffering and death, but also of His resurrection on the third day (verse 31; see also Mark 9:31, 10:34). The "story" of Jesus does not end at the cross or in the tomb; instead, it is followed by the resurrection. This, too, was foretold in the Old Testament: Hosea 6:2, Jonah 2:1.

Jesus’ words to Peter (verse 33) were stern—the very same words He spoke to Satan during the temptations in the wilderness (Matthew 4:10). They could also be translated as "Get behind Me!" (cf. Mark 1:17, 8:34): Peter wanted to set the direction, but leading the way belongs to Jesus. The role of a disciple is to walk behind one’s Master and follow Him. Even today, the order must remain the same: first Jesus and His will, and only then the human being and his or her will.

Peter was close to the truth (verse 29), yet at the same time far from it (verse 33). It is often the case that the most terrible heresy lies right alongside sound doctrine. Only slight variations distinguish it from the true teaching. Indeed, it has been suggested that Jesus’s remarks regarding false messiahs (Matthew 24:23–24) do not refer to opposites of the true Christ, but rather to imitators of Christ.

What happened on the cross is and remains foolishness to human reason (1 Cor 1:18–25). Yet, at the same time, it is the essential center of the Christian faith:

"For I resolved to know nothing while I was with you except Jesus Christ and him crucified."
(1 Cor 2:1-5)

On Following Jesus – Mark 8:34–38

Taking up the cross (verse 34) was a very dark image for Jesus' listeners. It brought to their minds those condemned to crucifixion, who—as their final act—had to carry the crossbar to the place of execution (John 19:17).

For us Christians today, carrying the cross is a more figurative and, at the same time, broader metaphor. It calls us to embrace everything that following Christ entails in our lives.

Some Jewish interpreters of the Old Testament compared the carrying of the cross to the occasion when Isaac had to carry the wood to the place of sacrifice, where Abraham intended to offer him as a sacrifice (Genesis 2:6).

The crucified person became an outcast from society. The Jews did not even want to mention those who had been crucified. In the same way, the Christian faith will always be rejected by this world.

Self-denial (verse 34) was surely a difficult word for Peter, who ended up denying Jesus (Mark 14:66–72). It is important to remember that Peter received forgiveness for that sin. Even today, the path of the prodigal son remains open on God’s part.

What does it mean to lose one’s life (verse 35)? It means submitting to God’s will instead of one’s own—a desire to follow Jesus and the path He has opened. The American missionary Jim Elliot aptly remarked: "He is no fool who gives up what he cannot keep, but he is a fool who gives up what he cannot lose!"

Jesus did not want to entice people to follow Him without counting the cost. A person must make a choice between God and the world; it is impossible to please both. The world will never reach an understanding with those who follow God’s will.

At this stage, the disciples could still have withdrawn from Jesus’ company. Soon, however, the journey toward Jerusalem and the cross of Golgotha ​​began. From then on, their fate was bound to Jesus: they had become known as his followers (cf. Mark 14:67).

Many of Jesus’ followers have had to follow His path, even unto suffering and death. The history of the Church is, to a great extent, a history of martyrs. Martyrs have lost their lives for the sake of Jesus. They have suffered physical death, but have avoided eternal death.

The world can be won over (verse 36) only by abandoning the Gospel. The Christian faith can never be in harmony with this world. The prince of this world is Satan (Luke 4:6). Therefore, this world will never submit to Christ—not even in so-called Christian nations.

The loss of the soul (verse 36, "forfeit his soul") can also be understood as a lost opportunity to become a child of God. It has, in fact, been suggested that one great source of anguish in perdition would be the memory of those moments when one could have set out on the path to heaven, but failed to do so.

In verse 37 it is asked: "For what can a man give in return for his soul?" A person can offer only one ransom for their soul.

"Truly no man can ransom another,
or give to God the price of his life,
for the ransom of their life is costly
and can never suffice, that he should
live on forever and never see the pit."
(Ps 49:7-10)

No human deed is sufficient—only the atoning work of Jesus on the cross of Golgotha. The blood of Jesus is the ransom for our lives.

An "adulterous generation" (verse 38) refers not only to sins involving the violation of the sixth commandment ("You shall not commit adultery"), but also to the fact that people have broken the covenant God established with them by giving them His law. Instead of choosing to follow God’s will, they have become followers of Satan. The Old Testament employs this same imagery—for instance, in the Book of the prophet Hosea, where the prophet’s marriage serves as a metaphor for the relationship between Israel and God (Hosea 1–3; cf. Ezekiel 23; see also Deuteronomy 32:5, Ezekiel 2:5).

When Jesus returns in the glory of His Father (verse 38; 2 Thess. 1:6–10), a person’s destiny will be determined by a single factor: their relationship with Jesus. It is not sin that leads to one’s perdition, but rather the rejection of the salvation offered by Jesus. There is not a single person in heaven who did not commit sin while on earth—everyone there is a forgiven sinner.