A Study Guide to the Gospel of Mark Chapter 10 – Who is the Greatest?
Read or listen The Gospel of Mark, Chapter 10 online (ESV, YouVersion)
From where to where? Mark 10:1
According to Papias, John the Presbyter (or "the Elder") criticized Mark for not writing things down in order. The word order in verse 1 has posed a challenge for biblical scholars. Does Mark mean that Jesus left Capernaum and traveled to Judea via the east side of the Jordan—as various translations have interpreted the verse? Or did he mean exactly what he wrote: that Jesus left Galilee for Judea, and from there went to the other side of the Jordan?
A literal interpretation would imply that Jesus traveled through Samaria a second time (compare John 4:1–43) on his way to Judea. Generally, pilgrims traveling from Galilee to Jerusalem did not pass through Samaria, but rather took a route east of the Jordan, as Jews and Samaritans were on poor terms with one another (John 4:9). Luke’s account of the beginning of this journey mentions that Jesus entered a Samaritan village where he and his companions were not welcomed (Luke 9:51–56). But did Jesus continue his journey to another Samaritan village, or did he shift to the route that runs east of the Jordan (Luke 9:56)?
If Jesus traveled through Samaria and only crossed from Judea to the east side of the Jordan, then verse 46 would imply a return to Judea; consequently, the events described in verses 2–45 would have taken place east of the Jordan. It is difficult, however, to conceive of a reason why Jesus would have gone to Judea after having already arrived east of the Jordan. On the other hand, the idea of traveling via the area east of the Jordan is understandable.
It has been suggested that verse 1 serves as a heading for Jesus’ journey from Galilee to Jerusalem (Mark 10:1–11:11). In this view, Mark would first state the destination, and only then the route taken. This is also a possibility, and it would explain why Jesus traveled along the eastern side of the Jordan.
In any case, the time in Galilee was now left behind. The teaching of the disciples gives way to the teaching of the crowds.
A Question About Divorce – Mark 10:2–12
The Pharisees tried to get Jesus to say something that would diminish his popularity among the people (verse 2). Perhaps they even hoped that the same thing would happen to Jesus as had happened to John the Baptist: that Jesus might say something that would lead Herod Antipas to arrest him as well. After all, they were in territory ruled by Herod Antipas (cf. Mark 6:17–29).
In Judaism, divorce was an accepted practice (compare Romans 2:17-24). The only discussion was about what was sufficient grounds for divorce (Matthew 19:3). The stricter school of Rabbi Shammai accepted only sexual immorality as grounds for dissolving a marriage, whereas the more lenient school of Rabbi Hillel permitted the issuance of a certificate of divorce for almost any reason—such as if food burned, or even if a man found a more beautiful woman.
The Pharisees appealed to Moses’ provision for a certificate of divorce (verse 4; Deuteronomy 24:1–4). However, the interpreters of the Law had misrepresented Moses. The Mosaic law of divorce was intended to protect the abandoned wife, for without a divorce certificate she could not remarry, which led to either poverty or prostitution. The interpreters of the Law, by contrast, had construed Moses’ words as a license for divorce. An exception had been turned into a rule. A provision originally designed to protect a woman had become an instrument for her subjugation—a kind of "return policy": if I am dissatisfied with my wife, I can simply send her back to her father’s house.
The discussion centered primarily on what Moses meant when he said that a man might “find something displeasing in his wife” (Deuteronomy 24:1). Perhaps the Pharisees expected Jesus to answer how he interpreted Moses’ permission for divorce—that is, on what grounds a certificate of divorce could be written.
Once again, Jesus surprised his opponents. He did not enter into a discussion about what Moses meant, but rather about what God intended when He established marriage. God intended for it to last until one of the spouses dies. Only God has the authority to separate those whom He has joined together (verse 9; see also Genesis 1:27, 2:24). Jesus regarded marriage as indissoluble. In Matthew’s account of Jesus’ teaching on this same subject, one exception is mentioned: the unfaithfulness of one spouse grants the other spouse permission—though not an obligation—to divorce (Matt 5:31–32, 19:9).
"It has also been taught that if a man wishes to divorce his wife, he must give her a certificate of divorce. But I say to you: anyone who divorces his wife for any reason other than sexual immorality causes her to commit adultery. And whoever marries a woman divorced by her husband also commits adultery."
(Matt 5:31-32, ESV)"And I say to you: whoever divorces his wife, except for sexual immorality, and marries another, commits adultery."
(Matt 19:9, ESV)
Verse 12 highlights a peculiarity of Jewish culture: only a man can issue a certificate of divorce, not a woman. In Hellenistic culture, women could also leave their husbands (Mark 6:17–18, Herodias). Within the Christian faith, the status of women was far better than it was in Judaism or paganism.
In verse 5, Jesus says that the hardness of people’s hearts was the reason Moses permitted divorce. Ezekiel 36:26–27 foretells a new covenant, in which God replaces a heart of stone with a heart of flesh:
“And I will give you a new heart, and a new spirit I will put within you. And I will remove the heart of stone from your flesh and give you a heart of flesh. And I will put my Spirit within you, and cause you to walk in my statutes and be careful to obey my rules.”
(Ezekiel 36:26–27, ESV)
Jesus wanted to go back past Moses to the beginning; to the time before the fall into sin. Jesus did not want to ask what is permitted, but rather what is God’s original, good will. Without sin, there would be no divorce either. The Messiah came to make a new, loving relationship between people possible. Unfortunately, in this world of imperfection, it often happens very poorly.
The Lutheran Church operates on the principle that the innocent party should not be punished, but rather has the right to enter into a new marriage (cf. 1 Cor 7:15).
Those considering divorce should remember that God never has only bad options. Often, far too little time and effort are spent on seeking a good option.
The Gospel for Children – Mark 10:13–16
Mark uses the Greek word paidion for children, which can refer to a small child or infant (John 16:21) or even a 12-year-old child (Mark 5:39–42). Luke uses the Greek word brephē, which specifically denotes an infant (Luke 18:15).
In Greek language, the form used for those who brought them is in the masculine gender. Thus, at least some of those who brought them were fathers.
Did the disciples think that children would not understand Jesus’ teaching, or did they believe that entering the kingdom of heaven requires a kind of faith that children cannot possess (verse 13)? Once again, Jesus surprised even the disciples. Children must not become adults to enter the kingdom of God, but adults must become like children if they want to be saved (verse 15).
This passage has often been misinterpreted, with the idea that children serve as an example because of their innocence. Note that in verse 15, Jesus speaks about receiving. The "strength" of children lies in their ability to receive unconditionally.
One significant aspect emerges from the situation at that time: a Jewish child became subject to the Law—a "son of the Law"—at the age of 13 (cf. Luke 2:42, 47). Consequently, children younger than this were not yet subject to the requirements of the Law of Moses; they were not expected to observe it. We, too, can be saved without fulfilling the works of the Law. Jesus fulfilled the entire Law on our behalf. We receive salvation as a gift from God. We just need to accept it.
Another quality we could learn from children is their trust in their parents. Father gives good gifts. (cf. Matt 7:7–11).
The early church found in this - as in other words of Jesus - the answer to the question of whether small children can be baptized: “Let the children come to me; do not hinder them, for to such belongs the kingdom of God.": (verse 14). This text is read even today as part of the Lutheran baptismal liturgy.
The Danger of Riches – Mark 10:17–27
The fact that the man ran after Jesus shows that he was in earnest (verse 17). A Jewish man would not typically run, and, naturally, it was not pleasant to do so under the scorching sun. Matthew mentions that the man was young (Matt 19:22), and Luke notes that he held a high position (Luke 18:18).
The man had tried—and, in his own view, even succeeded—to follow God’s will (verse 20), yet he still felt that his piety was not enough for eternal life.
In Judaism, there were so-called "tau people": they had fulfilled God’s commandments from aleph to tau—from the first letter of the Hebrew alphabet to the last—that is, from beginning to end (cf. Phil. 3:5–6).
Verse 18 has been perceived as difficult. One should not conclude from it that Jesus was not good. He is simply asking whether the man understands what he is saying—how he can call someone—whom he merely assumes to be a teacher—"good," when only God is good. A great mystery lies within this verse: Jesus is that God.
In verse 19, Jesus lists the commandments from the second tablet of the Law—those concerning one’s neighbor—but the ninth and tenth commandments are represented by the phrase “Do not defraud.” Jesus did not list the commandment according to the Law of Moses, nor even in its order.
The man claims to have kept those seven commandments—and, naturally, the three commandments from the first tablet of the Law as well (verse 20). "From my youth" refers to the Jews requiring observance of the law from the age of 13, at which time a Jewish boy becomes a "son of the law" (compare the explanation of verses 13-16).
In verse 21, the phrase “loved him” indicates that Jesus did not merely want to make the man aware of the shortcomings in his own spirituality, but truly to call him into the kingdom of God—to a share in eternal life (verse 17).
Jesus’ command to sell everything exposed a weak point in the man. He loved his possessions more than eternal life. It revealed that he was unable to fulfill even the first commandment—which, in fact, serves as the foundation and starting point for keeping all the other commandments.
Jesus’ exhortation also serves as a reminder that nothing should be more valuable than the kingdom of God (cf. Mark 9:42–48). We must be prepared to let go of everything that God wants us to give up.
Sometimes, the words of Jesus have been interpreted as applying to all times and all Christians. Yet, Jesus did not demand the same thing from everyone. Nicodemus was wealthy, but he was permitted to keep his possessions (John 3:1–21). The point is that Jesus seeks to remove our idols. In his Large Catechism—specifically in his explanation of the First Commandment—the Reformer Martin Luther aptly observed that a person’s (false) god is that upon which they feel dependent.
In verse 24, some manuscripts contain an addition: “those who trust in their possessions.”
Attempts have been made to resolve the difficulty in verse 25 by suggesting that there was a small gate in the wall of Jerusalem known as the "Eye of the Needle," through which a camel could pass only if it were unburdened—implying that one can enter the Kingdom of God only by casting off one's burdens.
Another attempt to make the implementation of this verse easier starts from the observation that by changing one letter in the word for "camel," one obtains a Greek word meaning "rope."
Such attempts to make the passage easier to accept are futile, for verses 26–27 reveal that Jesus was speaking of something impossible: the largest animal known at the time (cf. Matthew 23:24) passing through the smallest opening of that era (cf. Matthew 7:13–14; Luke 13:24). It means God demands the impossible from those who are to be saved—something no human being is capable of fulfilling.
It is not merely a matter of giving up possessions—the disciples had already done that (verse 28), and yet they still had to ask: “Who then can be saved?” (verse 26). Salvation is possible for God alone (verse 27). Therefore, it is solely the work of God. A human being cannot save themselves through any deeds (verse 17). Only God can do this.
Nothing is impossible for God (Genesis 18:14; Job 42:2; Zechariah 8:6). He—and He alone—can save a sinful human being.
The Disciple’s Reward – Mark 10:28-31
Peter felt that he and the other disciples had succeeded where the rich young man had failed: they had given up everything and followed Jesus (verse 28; cf. verse 21). Would they receive the reward the rich young man was seeking—namely, eternal life (verse 17)? “Yes,” Jesus answers (verse 30), but the lives of Jesus’ followers are transformed even in this present time, in this life. They have to give up much (verse 29), but in return, they receive a hundredfold (verse 30).
Note that a wife is not mentioned in the “lists of relatives” (verses 29 and 30). Some explain this by pointing out that Peter was married (Mark 1:30; 1 Cor. 9:5), but that is not the correct explanation. The relationship between spouses is unique: they are “one,” and God has joined them together (verse 9); therefore, God does not separate them. Spiritual movements that demand separation from spouses who are "without faith" act contrary to the Bible (1 Cor 7:10–16).
Note that God always gives more (verse 30) than what He requires (verse 29). Even if some relatives are lost, new brothers and sisters in the faith will take their place.
Life apart from God is an incomplete life. It lacks the deepest purpose of life, which can be found only in God. The life of a Christian is a full life.
Jesus provides a realistic description of the Christian life: a Christian may also experience difficulties and persecution (verse 30). Carrying the cross is an inseparable part of the Christian life (Mark 8:34).
Verse 31 contains a warning for Peter: “You are among the first of my followers; you have given up everything—but that does not mean you, too, could not fall away and end up being the last.”
Christian faith is not a matter of tactical calculation—the idea that by giving something up now, I will one day get it back with high interest. God alone determines the order of precedence in the kingdom of heaven (Mark 10:40)—not our piety, our deeds, or our giving up of various things.
The Third Prediction of the Passion – Mark 10:32–34
Mark emphasizes that, on the way to Jerusalem, Jesus walked ahead. Rabbis walked ahead of their disciples. A shepherd walks ahead of his flock. Mark’s point is that Jesus was leading the course of events.
Because Jerusalem was situated at a high elevation, it could be seen from as far away as a two-day journey. As the capital of the Jews came into view, the disciples began to wonder what might happen there. Jesus had already found Himself in conflict with the Pharisees and the teachers of the law (Mark 9:14). Was a final confrontation now at hand (verse 32)?
In verses 33–34, Jesus predicts his suffering, death, and resurrection for the third time (previous announcements of his suffering: Mark 8:31 and 9:31). Jesus’ words relate to the path of the Lord’s suffering servant in the Old Testament (Isaiah 53 and Isaiah 50:6)
"I gave my back to those who strike, and my cheeks to those who pull out the beard; I hid not my face from disgrace and spitting."
(Isaiah 50:6, ESV)
Places of Honor in the Kingdom of God – Mark 10:35-45
Each of the three announcements of Jesus’ suffering is followed by an account that demonstrates how little Jesus’ disciples understood (see Mark 8:31–38, 9:30–37). In each instance, the question of hierarchy—who is the greatest—also arises.
James and John were members of Jesus’ three-person “inner circle” (Mark 9:2–8).
The fact that there were twelve apostles suggests that they were the leaders of the twelve tribes of the new Israel (cf. Acts 1:21–22). John was Jesus’s most beloved disciple (John 13:23, 21:20), so the request was, in a sense, understandable.
Notice that Jesus does not promise the brothers that he will fulfill their request (verse 36). We can ask God for anything, but He does not give us just anything.
It is good to note in verse 37 that James and John believed that Jesus would come victorious in Jerusalem. They imagined that Jesus would establish a new kingdom, and they wanted to be its two most important leaders, second only to Jesus.
At the beginning of verse 38, the Greek text includes a “but”: Jesus does not promise to grant the disciples’ request. It is worth asking ourselves whether we are prepared to drink the cup that Jesus drank and to be baptized with the baptism with which Jesus was baptized! Are we capable of being cross-bearers?
In the Old Testament, the cup (verse 38) is a symbol of suffering—the "wine of wrath," representing God’s punishment (Psalm 75:8, Isa 51:17–23, Jer 25:15–28, Jer 49:12, Ezek 23:31–34).
"For in the hand of the Lord there is a cup with foaming wine, well mixed, and he pours out from it, and all the wicked of the earth shall drain it down to the dregs."
(Psalm 75:8, ESV)
Jesus also used the same metaphor in his prayer in Gethsemane and when forbidding Peter from using a sword:
"And he said, 'Abba, Father, all things are possible for you. Remove this cup from me. Yet not what I will, but what you will.'"
(Mark 14:36, ESV)"But Jesus said to Peter: 'Put your sword into its sheath! Since the Father has given Me this cup, shall I not drink it?'"
(John 18:11, ESV)
In this context, baptism (verse 38) corresponds here to the Old Testament imagery of drowning in deep waters (See also Ps 69:16, Ps 124:4–5, Isaiah 43:2, Luke 12:50 and Romans 6:3–4):
“For the waves of death encompassed me, the torrents of destruction assailed me"...
(2 Samuel 22:5, ESV)"Deep calls to deep at the roar of your waterfalls; all your breakers and your waves have gone over me."
(Psalm 42:8, ESV)
The brothers promised that they would follow Jesus (verse 39; compare Peter: Mark 14:29). It is quite evident that they did not at all understand what they were committing themselves to (Mark 9:32). Perhaps they thought Jesus was speaking of that baptism with fire—the victory over adversaries—which John the Baptist had foretold (Mark 1:8: "I have baptized you with water, but he will baptize you with the Holy Spirit"; compare Luke 3:16–17: "...He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and with fire. His winnowing fork is in his hand, and with it he will clear his threshing floor of grain. He will gather the wheat into his barn, but the chaff he will burn with a fire that never goes out.").
Places of honor in heaven belong to those for whom God has prepared them—before the foundation of the world (Matthew 25:34) (verse 40). Although James and John would indeed walk the path God had prepared for them, this did not guarantee the most prominent places in heaven. James suffered a martyr’s death at the hands of Herod Agrippa I in AD 42–44 (verse 39). John, by contrast, was likely the only one of the twelve apostles to die a natural death at an advanced age (cf. John 21:23).
Verse 40 contains a passive form—"prepared"—which, in this context as well, refers to the action of God. Verse 41 reveals that the other disciples were no holier than James and John, who had sought the foremost positions.
Verses 42–44 should not be understood to mean that one should not strive to move forward within the church. One should strive, but in a way different from that of the world: by seeking to fulfill God’s will, rather than one’s own.
Verse 44 intensifies teaching already presented. In Mark 9:35 Jesus said: “If anyone would be first, he must be last of all and servant of all.” Now the "servant" has shifted to a "slave."
In modern times, we are familiar with the concept of a ransom (verse 45) in the context of kidnappings. According to the Book of Exodus a ransom was used to redeem a slave or a prisoner of war, setting them free:
"If a ransom is imposed on him, then he shall give for the redemption of his life whatever is imposed on him."
(Exodus 21:30, ESV)
Jesus paid the ransom required for liberation on the cross at Golgotha:
"Truly no man can ransom another, or give to God the price of his life, for the ransom of their life is costly and can never suffice"...
..."But God will ransom my soul from the power of Sheol, for he will receive me."
(Psalm 49:7-8 and 15, ESV)..."who gave himself for us to redeem us from all lawlessness and to purify for himself a people for his own possession who are zealous for good works."
(Titus 2:14, ESV)..."he entered once for all into the holy places, not by means of the blood of goats and calves but by means of his own blood, thus securing an eternal redemption."
(Hebrews 9:12, ESV)."knowing that you were ransomed from the futile ways inherited from your forefathers, not with perishable things such as silver or gold but with the precious blood of Christ, like that of a lamb without blemish or spot."
(1 Peter 1:18-19, ESV)
In some Bible translations, verse 45 contains a literal rendering: “for many.” In Jewish thought, “many” stood in contrast to “one”—meaning, in effect, “everyone else” (This same distinction also appears in translations of the words of institution for the Lord’s Supper: Mark 14:24: “This is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many.").
The Last Healing Report – Mark 10:46-52
From Jericho (verse 46), it is only about 25 kilometers to Jerusalem. The road from Jericho was a good place for begging; many pilgrims traveled along it, and the city served as a vacation spot for the wealthy.
At the end of verse 46, there is a repetition: Bartimaeus means "son of Timaeus." Mark has translated the name into Greek but has also retained the Aramaic form.
Bartimaeus acknowledged Jesus as the Messiah (verse 47). "Son of David" was a title for the Messiah. In the Old Testament, this is addressed in passages such as the following:
"Behold, the days are coming, declares the Lord , when I will raise up for David a righteous Branch, and he shall reign as king and deal wisely, and shall execute justice and righteousness in the land. In his days Judah will be saved, and Israel will dwell securely. And this is the name by which he will be called: ‘The Lord is our righteousness.’"
(Jer 23:5-6, ESV)"And I will set up over them one shepherd, my servant David, and he shall feed them: he shall feed them and be their shepherd. And I, the Lord , will be their God, and my servant David shall be prince among them. I am the Lord ; I have spoken."
(Ezek 34:23-24, ESV)
Matthew recounts that as Jesus rode into Jerusalem, a rejoicing crowd called him the Son of David:
"And the crowds that went before him and that followed him were shouting, “Hosanna to the Son of David! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord! Hosanna in the highest!”
(Matt 21:9, ESV)
Bartimaeus’s cloak (verse 50) may have also served as a surface upon which passersby tossed alms. Casting it aside, therefore, could signify not only his haste to reach Jesus but also his abandonment of his former life as a beggar.
Jesus’ question, “What do you want me to do for you?” (verse 51), seems unnecessary, but it gives the blind man an opportunity to confess his faith. “Rabbouni” (verse 51) was a more respectful form of address than simply “Rabbi”.
Verse 51 reveals that the man had previously been able to see, but had lost his sight. In verse 52, what faith had done for the man can be translated as either “healed” or “saved.” It is often difficult to decide which way the Greek word in question should be translated, and different Bible translations have opted for one or the other.
The healing of the blind was one of the signs that the messianic age had dawned (Isaiah 42:7, 18). On this occasion, the healing is not followed by a prohibition against speaking about what happened, for the time of Jesus’s suffering and death is already drawing near. They arrive in Jerusalem that very evening. Now, it can be made known that Jesus is the Messiah.
This is the final healing story in the Gospel of Mark. In chapter 11, the report of Jesus' suffering begins.