A Study Guide to the Gospel of Mark Chapter 11 – Hosanna, Son of David!
Read or listen The Gospel of Mark, Chapter 11 online (ESV, YouVersion)
On the Evening of Palm Sunday – Mark 11:1–11
Jesus was traveling along the road from Jericho (Mark 10:46). As one approaches Jerusalem, the first village along the Jericho road was Bethany. One might expect Mark to have listed the villages in a different order: Bethany and Bethphage. The explanation for this surprising order may be quite simple: since Bethany was much better known of the two, Mark began with it. It has also been suggested that Mark—being from Jerusalem (Acts 12:12)—viewed matters specifically from the perspective of Jerusalem; in that case, Bethphage comes first, as it is closer to the city.
Bethany was located about three kilometers east of Jerusalem. It was the home village of Martha, Mary, and Lazarus (John 11:1–44). Today, the village is called El-Azariya, or “the village of Lazarus.” Bethany means “house of the poor” or “house of affliction.”
The location of Bethphage is somewhat uncertain, but in rabbinic literature it was considered part of Jerusalem, meaning the Passover lamb could be eaten there. Bethphage means "House of Figs." The village is not mentioned at all in the Old Testament.
Bethany was on the eastern slope of the Mount of Olives, while Bethphage was on the western slope, on the side descending toward the Kidron Valley. The village from which the donkey was fetched was likely Bethphage (verse 2). Mark mentions only a colt, which in this context—as was generally the case in Israel—referred to a donkey colt.
Mark does not quote Zechariah 9:9, like both Matthew 21:5 and John 12:15 do.
"Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion! Shout aloud, O daughter of Jerusalem! Behold, your king is coming to you; righteous and having salvation is he, humble and mounted on a donkey, on a colt, the foal of a donkey."
(Zech. 9:9)
An earthly conquering king would have ridden a horse. A donkey was a sign of humility (cf. Zech 9:9). Jesus did not come to start a war; He came as the Prince of Peace (Isa 9:5). The Rabbis taught that the Messiah would come on a donkey if Israel were sinful.
Samuel had given advice to Saul—Israel’s future first king—on how to find some lost donkeys (1 Sam 10:2–8). Now, Jesus provides guidance to his disciples in a similar way (verse 2).
It has been suggested that Jesus may have arranged to borrow the donkey during a previous visit to Jerusalem (verses 4–6). Another possible explanation for the borrowing of the donkey is that its owner was a disciple of Jesus—this being one way to serve the Master.
Throwing garments onto the road was a gesture of royal respect (verse 8; see 2 Kings 9:12–13).
John states that the people took palm branches (John 12:13). It has been suggested that there were not many palm trees in Jerusalem at that time; however, palm branches are specifically mentioned in connection with the triumphal procession of Simon Maccabeus—about 200 years earlier (1 Maccabees 13:51). Of course, it is possible that the people had brought palm branches with them from Jericho, from where they had set out on their journey in the morning. After all, Jericho was known as the City of Palms.
"Hosanna" (verse 9) can be translated as "O (Lord), help," "help now," or "save." Originally, it was used when seeking help from an earthly king (2 Samuel 14:4; 2 Kings 6:26), but in the time of Jesus, it was a plea—or rather, an expression of praise—directed toward God or the Messiah (Psalm 118:25).
Verse 9 is a quotation from Psalm 118:25–26, which was regarded as a messianic prophecy:
"Save us, we pray, O LORD! O LORD, we pray, give us success! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord ! We bless you from the house of the Lord."
(Psalm 118:25–26, ESV)
Different gospels describe different shouts of praise from the people; Matthew 21:9: “Son of David”, Luke 19:38: “King” and John 12:13: “King of Israel”.
The four gospels describe different shouts of praise from the people; Matthew 21:9: “Son of David”; Luke 19:38: “King” and John 12:13: “King of Israel”. It is clear that the crowd shouted in different ways—some used one expression, others another. All four expressions found in the Gospels point to the same thing: the people’s expectation of a worldly Messiah. They were looking for a new Davidic king. For this reason, Jesus had wanted to keep his messianic identity hidden during his public ministry: he did not want to be regarded as a leader of a rebellion (compare John 6:14–15).
Some of those traveling along the slope of the Mount of Olives likely regarded Jesus as a prophet—a man of God. Others may have simply wanted to provoke the Romans a little. In a sense, it was a demonstration—there was open talk of a King of the Jews, even though everyone was, of course, supposed to swear allegiance to the Roman Emperor (cf. 2 Samuel 7:11–14, God’s promise to David).
"Hosanna in the highest" (verse 11) could also mean "send your help from the heights". Already early on, the Hosanna hymn was associated with the celebration of the Lord's Supper. For in it, the King of heaven comes into the midst of His people and brings them help.
Verse 11 reveals that Jesus rode into Jerusalem on the evening of Palm Sunday.
Not all pilgrims found a place to stay in Jerusalem; some had to spend the night in nearby villages. Jesus and his disciples stayed in Bethany—apparently at the home of Martha, Mary, and Lazarus (John 12:1–3)—though another suggested location is the house of Simon the leper (cf. Mark 14:3). Furthermore, it was safer for Jesus to stay outside Jerusalem, given that the Jewish leadership was seeking his life (Mark 11:18; John 11:45–57).
It is difficult to say how significant an event Jesus’ entry into Jerusalem was. Had it been a major act of rebellion, Roman forces would likely have intervened (compare Acts 21:27–40). On the other hand, it is worth remembering that even today, crowds know how to provoke those in power just enough—effectively, yet with sufficient restraint to avoid triggering an intervention.
Had the entry into Jerusalem been interpreted as an act of insurrection, it surely would have been brought up when Jesus was accused before Pilate. However, our information on this point is also incomplete; we do not know the full extent of the accusations leveled against Jesus. Yet, based on the Gospels, it appears that his opponents were unable to present any concrete charge against him (John 19:4). The mention in Matthew 21:10 of the entire city of Jerusalem being in a stir may simply mean that Jesus’s entry into the city was common knowledge, and that it became a subject of discussion and debate. Apparently, public enthusiasm declined as quickly as it had risen.
Monday Morning – Mark 11:12-14
Between the cursing of the fig tree (verse 14) and its withering (verse 20), Mark recounts Jesus’ cleansing of the temple. These two events are, therefore, connected. Both ought to have borne fruit, but as both proved fruitless, they were subjected to destruction. The fig tree withered the following night; the temple in Jerusalem was destroyed about forty years later, in 70 AD.
The fig tree growing by the roadside was exceptionally early. Usually, leaves do not appear until after Easter (verse 13). From such an unusual tree, one might expect to find early figs—which, on some fig trees, appear even before the leaves (Isaiah 28:4; Mark 13:28). The spring crop of figs would typically be harvested in June, with a second crop in August. However, no fruit was found. The tree was beautiful and leafy, but useless.
In the Old Testament, Israel was often compared to a fig tree:
"Like grapes in the wilderness, I found Israel. Like the first fruit on the fig tree in its first season, I saw your fathers. But they came to Baal-peor and consecrated themselves to the thing of shame, and became detestable like the thing they loved."
(Hosea 9:10, ESV)"When I would gather them, declares the LORD, there are no grapes on the vine, nor figs on the fig tree; even the leaves are withered, and what I gave them has passed away from them.”
(Jeremiah 8:13, ESV)
See also Micah 7:1–7 and the sermon of John the Baptist:
"Even now the axe is laid to the root of the trees. Every tree therefore that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire.”
(Luke 3:9)
and the parable of the unfruitful fig tree:
"And he told this parable: “A man had a fig tree planted in his vineyard, and he came seeking fruit on it and found none. And he said to the vinedresser, ‘Look, for three years now I have come seeking fruit on this fig tree, and I find none. Cut it down. Why should it use up the ground?’ And he answered him, ‘Sir, let it alone this year also, until I dig around it and put on manure. Then if it should bear fruit next year, well and good; but if not, you can cut it down.’”'
(Luke 13:6-9, ESV)
Mark appears to want to emphasize that the Temple in Jerusalem—and Israel more broadly—ought to have borne fruit before other nations, given that it was a place consecrated to God. But when it was found to be fruitless, its destruction was near (cf. Luke 19:41–44).
This is the only miracle of cursing recorded in the Gospels. The prophets of the Old Testament pronounced similar judgments of cursing (2 Kings 2:23–24).
The Cleansing of the Temple – Mark 11:15–19
The Temple complex in Jerusalem measured approximately 450 by 300 meters. In addition to the Temple itself, the area included three courtyards: the Court of the Gentiles on the outside, the Court of the Women, and the Court of the Men, which was closest to the Temple itself. Commercial activity took place in the Court of the Gentiles. In this way, the Jewish religious leaders had deprived the Gentiles of the only place where they could have prayed to the living God (1 Kings 8:41–43).
Gentiles were forbidden from entering the Court of Women, under penalty of death. Near the gate, there was a sign in Greek stating this prohibition; one such sign has been discovered during archaeological excavations. The entry of a Gentile into areas reserved exclusively for Jews would have resulted in the defilement of the entire Temple (cf. Acts 21:28).
There were practical reasons for this commerce. Since sacrificial animals could be purchased in the temple courtyard, pilgrims did not need to bring them along—which was helpful, given that some had traveled from far away. However, the temple’s high-ranking clergy, who oversaw this trade, began to mandate that only animals purchased at the temple itself were acceptable for sacrifice. After all, a priest was required to inspect each animal and certify it as suitable (Leviticus 22:17–30). And because only animals bought at the temple qualified for sacrifice, this trade generated a substantial profit.
Pagan money was to be exchanged for one that did not contain idolatry (verse 15). There were two such types of currency: the old Jewish shekels (Exodus 30:12–16) and silver coins minted by the King of Tyre—which, in fact, did bear an image of an idol, but because the coins were of a consistent standard, the image was interpreted as something else (compare Mark 12:13–17).
One could take a shortcut through the temple courtyards when traveling from the Kidron Valley or the Mount of Olives toward the western part of the city—the center of Jerusalem (verse 16). The Jewish religious leadership had also prohibited such passage. The term translated as "anything" (verse 16) could also be translated as "any vessel."
The prohibition on passage and the ban on sales remind us that matters of faith cannot be resolved solely from the perspective of utility or practicality. We must ask for God’s will—what He wants us to do.
During Easter, more than 100,000 pilgrims arrived in Jerusalem. Consequently, commerce was immense, generating substantial profits for the high priesthood and the Great Council, who oversaw it. Within the Temple precincts were the "Shops of Annas"—a marketplace controlled by the former high priest. According to tradition, a single seller of sacrificial animals might have had as many as 3,000 sheep for sale. Worship had turned into a business. One often encounters the same thing today at the sacred sites of various religions.
Jesus fulfilled Zechariah’s prophecy regarding the cleansing of the temple (Zech 14:20–21):
..."And there shall no longer be a trader in the house of the LORD of hosts on that day."
(Zech. 14:21b)
In verse 17, the word “taught” is in a Greek tense that denotes repeated and continuous action.
Verse 17 combines two Old Testament prophecies: Isaiah 56:7 foretold that all nations would come to the temple in Jerusalem to serve the living God, while Jeremiah 7:11 contains a warning against turning the temple into a den of robbers. Take note of Isaiah’s prophecy regarding all nations!
Malachi 3:1–13 contains a prophecy that God will send His messenger to purify the Chosen People.
“Behold, I send my messenger, and he will prepare the way before me. And the Lord whom you seek will suddenly come to his temple; and the messenger of the covenant in whom you delight, behold, he is coming, says the Lord of hosts." ...
(Malachi 3:1, ESV)
Both Jesus’ popularity among the people and the hostility of his opponents toward him grew (verse 18). Earlier (Mark 3:6), Mark had already mentioned the plan by the Pharisees and the supporters of Herod to kill Jesus. Now, the Jewish leaders feared two things (verse 18): on one hand, Jesus might disrupt their business activities, and on the other, an uprising could break out if the temple police and Jesus’ followers were to clash. A rebellion would lead to punitive measures by the Romans (cf. John 11:45–57).
Jesus likely could not have cleared out the entire trading area. In fact, by the following day, money changing appears to have been underway once again (Mark 12:13–17). It was a matter of a sign: God’s judgment begins with the community of believers (1 Peter 4:17). It is futile to imagine that various religious practices will be of any help if the heart is far from God (see Isaiah 58).
John recounts that Jesus also cleansed the temple at the beginning of his public ministry (John 2:13–17). In all likelihood, this task would have needed to be repeated time and time again. It was only the destruction of the temple that put an end to the trading.
The Jews did not allow the Gentiles to pray in peace in the Court of the Gentiles. Fortunately, Christians have built the “Church of All Nations” in Gethsemane. The message about Jesus belongs to all nations.
Tiistaiaamuna – Mark 11:20-26
Apparently, they had spent the night in the same place as the previous night, for on Tuesday morning they passed by the fig tree once again. On Monday evening, the tree must still have been alive—unless Jesus had taken a different route that evening, which is unlikely—but now it was dead. The fact that it had withered down to its roots (verse 20; cf. Job 18:16–21, Hosea 9:16) indicates that its destruction was complete and final. A little later, Jesus predicts the same fate for the Temple in Jerusalem (Mark 13:2). That prophecy was fulfilled some forty years later, in AD 70, when Roman forces conquered Jerusalem.
Once again, Peter acts as the spokesman for the disciples (verse 21). Verse 22 reveals the most important thing: faith in God. Miracles are the works of God. They can only be done through faith.
Paul also writes about faith that can move mountains (verse 23), but he explains that love is even more important:
..."and if I have all faith, so as to remove mountains, but have not love, I am nothing."
(1 Cor 13:2)
An interesting point of comparison is also offered by Isaiah 54:10: God’s covenant of peace is more enduring than the mountains and the hills.
"For the mountains may depart and the hills be removed, but my steadfast love shall not depart from you, and my covenant of peace shall not be removed,” says the LORD, who has compassion on you."
(Isaiah 54:10)
The image of faith that moves mountains is a powerful testament to the strength of faith. At the same time, it serves as a reminder of the weakness of our own faith.
The fact that one does not wish to forgive one’s neighbor (verse 25) reveals that there is no genuine faith in one’s heart in the God who forgives sins. Consequently, one also does not know how to pray correctly.
Verse 26 is missing from the best Greek manuscripts, so it has been omitted from several Bible translations.
By What Authority – Mark 11:27–33
The day of Tuesday continues (verse 27). Representatives from all three factions of the Great Council came to question Jesus’ authority. The elders were the leaders of the most prominent families; they should not be confused with the elders mentioned in the Acts of the Apostles and the New Testament epistles, who are the leaders of Christian congregations (Acts 20:17).
The primary reason for the question was evidently the cleansing of the temple that had taken place the previous day (verses 15–18), but Jesus’ authority had already been questioned on earlier occasions by the people (Mark 1:27) and the teachers of the law (Mark 2:6–12; John 1:18–22). John the Baptist had also been questioned regarding his authority (John 1:19–28).
If we consider that the issue concerned, specifically, the cleansing of the Temple in Jerusalem, the question was whether Jesus had the authority to intervene in matters pertaining to the temple. The only body that could have granted such authority was the Sanhedrin—yet it was precisely this body that was now questioning Jesus’s credentials. This left two possibilities: either Jesus’s authority came from God, or it came from human beings—who, of course, had no right to grant it. Ultimately, then, we can say that the real question was: is Jesus acting on behalf of God or on behalf of Satan? (cf. Mark 3:20–30).
The questioners likely hoped to obtain something they could use to accuse Jesus, either before the Great Council or before the Roman authorities (cf. Mark 12:13).